■ News report quotes FNN offering US$4bn for a 45% stake in Vinamilk; FNN denies formal offer
■ Not surprising for FNN to show interest; already owns 11% stake
■ Funding, if any, through a combination of debt/ equity
■ A strategic game-changer if deal sees fruition
FNN offering US$4bn for a 45% stake in Vinamilk: Saigon Times. According to Bloomberg (appended), quoting Saigon Times, FNN is offering US$4bn for Vietnam’s State Capital Investment Corporation’s (SCIC) 45.1% stake in Vinamilk (VNM VN). FNN has issued an announcement indicating that it “has not submitted any offer letter to Vinamilk or SICC with regards to any offer to purchase SCIC’s stake in Vinamilk”.
Strategic price of 40% premium. The quoted offer price is about 40% premium to Vinamilk’s current traded price and values it at a market cap of US$8.9bn. This works out to a PE of 28x/25x on FY15F/16F, based on Bloomberg consensus’ estimates. While the price may look high, we believe the stake is of strategic value and particularly so with Vinamilk’s market leading status.
What do we think?
FNN is definitely an interested party, in our view. We believe there is a possibility that FNN is interested in increasing its stake in Vinamilk. FNN currently holds an 11% investment stake, is the second largest shareholder after SCIC, and the largest foreign shareholder. FNN has been a shareholder in Vinamilk since Feb 2005, and we believe they have been a patient strategic investor waiting on the sidelines for SCIC to divest. If the report were to be true, we believe its patience could be paying off.
Makes sense on the deployment of cash from MBL’s divestment. This development, if true, is not exactly surprising, and would make sense in our view. We have earlier indicated that FNN would be looking to “crawl back” the profit from the divestment of its 55% stake in Myanmar Brewery Limited earlier this year. This was post the arbitration outcome with its JV partner there. We estimate that FNN will be sitting on a cash pile to the tune of S$1.18bn by FYE Sep’15 year end.
Funding – likely a combination of internal cash, debt and equity. At this initial stage and based on the figures quoted by the Saigon Times, we believe the initial figure looks huge. If it were to materialise, we believe FNN would tap on its current cash horde, coupled with funding from equity and debt sources. Based on our back-of-envelope calculation, and using an approximate net gearing ratio of 0.8x, we estimate the funding would be 23%/ 55%/ 21% internal cash/ debt / equity.
News likely to drum up other suitors’ interest. We believe there could be a certain element of truth to the news report, but the details (ie price, and development) could be overplayed. In our view, the purpose of such news development could be to drum up potential suitors’ interest in bid to further up the ante and competition, in hope of a better price.
Fruition would be a game changer for FNN. At the quoted price, it seems high, but we believe it would be viewed from a strategic perspective and a game changer for FNN. This would allow FNN to firmly entrench its entry into Vietnam, one of the largest consumer markets in Indochina. Furthermore, we believe it would allow the introduction of its non-alcoholic and dairy brands, leveraging on Vinamilk’s dominant presence.
Recommendation and TP unchanged for now. (Read Report)
Source : DBS Group Research